What is the purpose of the South Cowichan Community Issues Assessment?

    The CVRD, in consultation with the Ministry of Municipal Affairs, has launched a South Cowichan Community Issues Assessment. This project will help to better understand the community’s current issues and concerns around governance and local servicing. 

    The intent of this work is: 

    • To provide the South Cowichan community with information about their current model of governance and servicing (e.g. water, parks, policing).
    • Update and identify new issues or concerns around governance and servicing from South Cowichan residents, service providers, and First Nations communities.

    Who is funding the South Cowichan Community Issues Assessment?

    The project is funded by a grant from the Provincial Ministry of Municipal Affairs.

    Why is the CVRD undertaking this project now?

    In 2023/24, due to fiscal and capacity pressures, the CVRD Board did not approve a budget for a Governance and Services Study, understanding that if provincial funding was secured there would still need to be a significant investment from the CVRD. After consultation with staff at the Ministry of Municipal Affairs, it was determined that a more cost effective and strategic approach would be to conduct a Community Issues Assessment. This would provide the South Cowichan communities with information about current governance and service delivery arrangements, update and clearly identify any related concerns and issues.

    Is this project to determine if we will become a municipality?

    No. The South Cowichan Community Issues Assessment will not provide a recommendation as to whether or not South Cowichan Communities should become a municipality or outline any changes in service delivery. However, it will help residents and the CVRD understand the current situation better, determine if service or governance gaps exist, and where to focus efforts for the South Cowichan.

    What are the outcomes of this project?

    This project will result in a South Cowichan Governance and Servicing Report and South Cowichan Community Issues Assessment – What we Heard Report.

    This report will:

    • Outline the roles, responsibilities and jurisdictions of service providers.
    • Present information on existing service delivery arrangements and governance relationships and how decisions are made.
    • Layout the current and emerging issues and pressures related to services, as seen by residents, property owners, improvement districts, and First Nations neighbours.

    The report will not

    • Include a review of options for governance change or an examination of municipal incorporation.
    • Provide any technical or financial information on the current situation or comparison of change to the current governance. 
    • Present governance options or make recommendations on changes to the existing governance model.

    What happens next?

    The South Cowichan Community Issues Assessment report will help the CVRD identify next steps and/or where to best focus efforts. The report is expected by the end of 2024. Following completion of the study, the CVRD will convey the findings to the Minister of Municipal Affairs. Depending on the results of this work and decisions by the CVRD Board, further steps towards a governance review and/or changes for CVRD Electoral Areas A, B and C, may be considered, if warranted.

    What does “servicing” mean?

    For this project, servicing refers to the engineering infrastructure works and related management and planning services that are required to meet the needs of residents. For example, roads, water supply, sewer, garbage collection, parks and recreation facilities, planning, policing, etc. Note: Not all of these services are provided by the CVRD, see FAQ question – “Who takes care of what services in the South Cowichan Electoral Areas?”

    What is a Regional District?

    A regional district is a governance model for larger areas (a region). A regional district is made up of municipalities, electoral areas, and in some cases, Treaty First Nations, each of which have representation on the Regional District Board. Regional Districts provide:

    Region-wide services such as regional parks, and emergency services.

    • Inter-municipal or sub-regional services, such as recreation facilities where residents of a municipality and residents in areas outside the municipality benefit from the service.
    • planning and land use management services to CVRD electoral areas. 

    What is an Electoral Area?

    Electoral areas are the communities located outside municipal boundaries, often referred to as rural or unincorporated areas. Each electoral area is represented by a director, who is elected directly to the regional district Board of Directors.

    What is a Municipality?

    Municipalities can be classified as either a town, village, district or city depending on the size of their population and geographic area. The B.C. government sets out legislation that provides municipalities with the authority for things like, planning parks, community water systems, local police, roadways and parking, and flexibility to respond to the varying needs and changing circumstances of each community. The province regards municipalities as autonomous, responsible and accountable government directed by democratically elected councils.

    What is the difference between a Regional District and a Municipality?

    The table summarizes some of the key differences between a regional district and municipality. 

     

    Municipality

    Regional District

    Governance

    Elected Mayor & Council

     

    Regional District Board made up of elected representatives from member municipalities, electoral (rural) areas, and Treaty First Nations. 

     

    Decision-making

    Democratically elected Mayor and Council make decisions on behalf of the community.

     

    Regional District Board members collectively make decisions on issues and needs of residents in the whole region. Board members vote on sub-regional services where they are service participants.

    Authority

    Municipal Councils typically have full discretion to set policies, adopt bylaws and establish direction for their communities in accordance with legislation and other legal rules.

    Corporate and service powers are similar for both municipalities and regional districts; however regional districts have more limited regulatory powers than municipalities.

    Powers and responsibility

    Local Government Act and Community Charter.

    Local Government Act and Community Charter.

    Taxes

    Municipalities collect taxes to pay for administration, planning and services.

    The province collects taxes and charges a collection fee. 

    Servicing

    Municipalities deliver services, including drinking water, roads, fire protection and sewage collection and treatment.

    Regional districts are obligated to provide very few services, including emergency management, planning for regional solid waste management, and governance for electoral areas. Regional districts have no role in roads and policing, as these services are provincial responsibilities. 

    Regional districts can provide a broad range of services. It is often said that regional districts can provide the services that their participants are prepared to pay for and the geographic boundaries of each service can be customized to match the area that benefits with the area that pays.

    Planning

    Municipalities are able to control land use and development using a variety of processes and tools, including official community plans and regulations such as zoning.

    Regional districts are able to regulate land use and development in electoral areas using generally the same planning and land use management processes and tools available to municipalities. However, regional districts differ from municipalities in that, they do not have a direct role in approving the subdivision of land (a provincial responsibility in non-municipal areas).

    Who takes care of what services in South Cowichan Electoral Areas?

    The following table outlines key services and their respective providers in the South Cowichan Electoral Areas.

     

    Service

    Responsibility

    General Administration

    CVRD, Regional District Board, Improvement Districts, Province, Admin Office in Duncan

    Community Planning & Development

    CVRD (zoning & OCP) and Province (subdivision & approval of the OCP)

    Building Permits

    CVRD

    ALR Status

    Agricultural Land Commission (Provincial)

    Water

    CVRD & Improvement Districts (responsible for water system planning) & Private Utilities, Private Wells

    Sewers

    Residents & Private Utilities

    Drainage

    Province, with small-area works by the CVRD

    Fire Protection

    CVRD & Improvement Districts (3)

    Policing

    Federal/Province (via contract with the RCMP), Electoral Areas pay approximately 30% of policing costs, Province/RCMP determine policing levels

    Bylaws (animal control, noise control, unsightly premises, signage) & Bylaw Enforcement

    CVRD, acts primarily on complaints

    Parks & Recreation

    CVRD (Parks and Trails) – regional and community parks

    Roads

    Province, maintenance, repair and upgrading of local roads and bridges

    Street Lighting

    CVRD, Shawnigan Improvement District

    Garbage Disposal

    CVRD, recycling is CVRD service with a separate user fee in each electoral area

    Property Tax Collection

    Province, charges a collection fee, Water Improvement Districts collect their own parcel taxes and user fees

    Emergency Management

    CVRD

    Watershed Protection

    CVRD (Watershed planning) & Province (Water licensing, watershed planning), Private Community Groups

    Transit

    CVRD (Facilities & Transit Division) in partnership with BC Transit and Transdev Canada

    Are CVRD services provided on a cost recovery basis?

    Yes. Most regional district services are optional. Generally, a regional district must adopt a service establishing bylaw to provide a new service to the community. This bylaw outlines what the service is, how it will be delivered, who will benefit, the maximum cost, and how the costs will be apportioned, or divided between service participants.